Follow me!
Gender Mystique

When did pink become a feminine color?

1/3/2012

14 Comments

 
The most frequent question I am asked is "When did pink become a feminine color?" It may seem simple -- it certainly did to me when I first went looking for an answer about thirty years ago -- but the answer actually depends on several factors. I have noticed that even when an article about my research is based on an interview with me, the author may try to settle on a single date rather than relate the whole messy tale. I completely understand. It took me an entire chapter in my book to answer that "simple" question! Here goes:

If you mean "When was pink first considered a feminine color by some culture somewhere in the world", I have no idea. Color symbolism is highly culture-specific and variable. (Consider, for example, that white was the traditional color of mourning in Japan at the same time that black had the same meaning in most of Europe.) It is clear that in most of Europe and America in the 19th century and early 20th century, pastel colors were considered "youthful" and were used more often to flatter the complexion, not denote gender. Pink was considered more flattering for brown-eyed, brown-haired people and blue for blue-eyed people. (Green and yellow were preferred for red-heads, and I have anecdotal evidence that lavender was sometimes used for African-American babies, but not enough to be confident in that claim.) When pink or blue were used in gendered ways, it seemed to be a matter of fashion -- a temporary trend -- not a tradition. Nor were they used consistently the way we do today (pink=girl, blue=boy).

Between (very) roughly 1900 and around 1940, there was a movement towards more gender distinction in clothing, first for toddlers and then for babies, including more frequent use of pink and blue to signify gender. There was also quite a bit of confusion among clothing manufacturers and retailers about which was which, as they tried to settle on one rule for the entire country. (See the table from 1927 in the image gallery)

Between around 1940 and the mid-1980s, the pink=girl, blue=boy convention was nearly uniform, but not completely so. This was still variable by region in the United States. There were German Catholic areas in Nebraska which used blue for girls as late as the early 1980s, and I have seen pink clothes for boys from the deep South from the 1970s. In addition, it was not yet the very rigid use of pink we've seen recently. Pink was an option for girls, and it was quite possible to avoid it. (I seldom wore pink or pastels as a little girl in the 1950s; my mother preferred to dress me in deeper colors, especially shades of blue.) Pink was by far the most common color used for first birthday cakes, for example, and pink and blue were used together in baby announcements, receiving blankets, toys and clothing for both boys and girls. 

What has changed since the 1980s? First, pink became so strongly associated with femininity, that when a boy or man wears it is is no longer "just a color", but an act of defiance or personal expression beyond the aesthetic. Second, it eventually crowded out other colors in the options for babies and little girls. Finally, pink has been adopted by manufacturers of thousands of products as a way to differentiate their wares and sell more items, especially for children.

So there it is. Before 1900, pink and blue were two of a range of pastels appropriate for babies and children, symbolic of gender to the same extent that shamrocks symbolized luck -- in a light-hearted, fanciful way, not a moral imperative. From 1900 to around 1940, their modern associations were taking shape, but were often reversed in some parts of the United States, and still not taken too seriously. From around 1940 until the mid-1980s, pink and blue had their now-familiar associations, with regional exceptions and lots of other options. Since around 1985, pink has been not only a strong symbol of femininity, but neutral and non-pink options have been gradually edged out. 

Sorry this is so long. But as you can see, the question may seem simple, but the answer is not!
14 Comments
Florence
6/24/2012 08:08:00 am

The comment about color and complexion reminded me of Laura Ingalls Wilder's books. In one of them, I think "Little House on the Prairie", she mentions that Ma always put blue ribbons in Mary's hair and brown in Laura's because of their hair colors. One chaotic morning Ma mixes up the ribbons and puts pink ones in her blond daughter's hair and blue in her brunette daughter's hair. The girls are delighted at the change, but Ma is embarrassed as it's apparently a major social rule that blue is for blondes and pink is for brunettes.

Reply
Holly
2/15/2014 04:28:57 am

Wonderful perspective! I work in an early 19th century Greek Revival building that has been converted to a portrait gallery. The walls were repainted to the building's original interior color- light pink. As the building was originally a bank, people find it very strange and often comment on it. I knew that pink was not referred to as a feminine color in the time the building was constructed. It is always great to have more tidbits about the history of the color pink!

Reply
Evelyn Cain
3/31/2014 02:06:37 am

I was born in 19223 and the folks' bank provided a little coin bank that was given to me and it was all blue with gold lettering. My brother was born five years later and he got a coin bank like mine except the front of the bank was pink. About the time my daughter was born in 1963, the term "Think pink" was the theme, referring to girls.

Reply
Jo Paoletti
3/31/2014 03:08:05 am

Thank you so much for the personal historical insight! May I ask where you and your brother were born? The variations were once very regional, and I can add it to my map!

Reply
Chris Jones
9/24/2015 01:26:16 pm

You were born in 19223? Wow! I guess they now have time machines.

Reply
Jo
9/25/2015 10:47:14 am

I am calculating Evelyn was in her 90s when she posted. Having committed my share of typos in my own lifetime, I'm in no position to criticize her! (Also, I can't edit posts, so her typo is immortal.)

Ed
8/12/2015 01:17:22 pm

It was my understanding that at the turn of the prior century Victorian/Edwardian era (?) a British royal bucked the current trend of female blue/ male pink when selecting colors for her wedding and chose pink, creating a trend for women to wear pink.
Am I mistaken?

Reply
Jo
8/14/2015 02:50:55 am

I am not familiar with this particular story, but it could have happened. Of course, it is sort of anachronistic to describe an action in the 19th century as "bucking the current trend", but I know what you mean. It is unlikely that a single action set the trend, though, especially considering that pink was not "universally" seen a feminine color until the mid-twentieth century.

Reply
Lucy Schwieger
3/30/2016 08:28:29 pm

In Christianity boys wore red to honor the sacred heart of Jesus and girls wore Blue in honor of The Blessed Virgin Mary. Twin girls one could be dedicated to Jesus and wear red ribbons while the other to Mary and wear blue ribbons.

Reply
Jo
4/9/2016 06:51:25 pm

I know that blue was often a feminine color in parts of Germany, Belgium, and Switzerland. I had not heard about the symbolism of red. Do you have any idea where this was traditional, and when?

Reply
Shirley Breitenstein
8/10/2016 08:29:04 pm

I just listened to QI (Steven Fry's British Program) and the blue-pink was for babies was mentioned. You are right on - but even though I was born in 1935, I was unaware of the pockets in the US that remained with the ways of the 1900's. Thank you! PS - QT can be see on ACORN Channel and is hillarious and excellent!

Reply
Jo
8/11/2016 11:14:17 am

Thanks for the tip, Shirley! I will go take a listen. (Big fan of Stephen Fry, anyway!)

Reply
Kia
5/15/2018 12:58:02 pm

I heard that pink became a feminine color because of the holocaust. They made gay men wear pink triangles on there uniforms.

Reply
Jo Paoletti
5/16/2018 10:45:47 am

I have also heard that, but there's not much evidence to support it.

The problems with the Nazi-pink triangle explanation are multiple. It is too simple. The symbolic messages are too mixed.The timing is wrong. Where do I begin?

It is too simple If I am sure about anything after decades of studying fashion, it is that simple connections make great stories, but usually bad explanations. Pink and blue symbolism became popular in the United States over the course of several generations, and varied considerably by region, even after 1940. This made me skeptical that pink triangles in Germany somehow quickly effected change in the US. Furthermore, the pink triangle was not a universal symbol for homosexuality in the German camps. It is most commonly associated with Dachau (other camps had their own systems) and was used for sexual offenders, not just for homosexual men.

The symbolic messages are too mixed. Pink symbolizes male homosexuality. Or femininity. Or communist sympathies. Or romance. Or sexuality (in the olden days, pornographic images that showed female genitals were called "pink shots".) You get the picture.

The timing is wrong. The use of pink badges was more common in the middle and later years of the war, and the general American public knew very little about the realities and details of the concentration camps until later. My research places the "tipping point" for pink being considered a feminine color in most (not all!!) of the U.S. sometime in the 1930s, later rather than earlier. Some articles turn this into "around 1940" in order to connect it with the Nazi pink triangle. tsk tsk.

The other timing issue is that in the 1940s and 1950s, homosexuality was still a taboo subject. The pink triangle did not really emerge in the American symbolic lexicon until the late 1970s at the earliest, and for many straight Americans was unknown until the 1990s. This makes it unlikely that parents and manufacturers associated pink with the Nazi symbolism in the 1940s.

The bottom line, in my opinion, is that the dots between the Nazi pink triangle and pink as a little girls' color are strictly imaginary.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Jo Paoletti

    Professor Emerita
    ​American Studies
    University of Maryland

    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    February 2020
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    February 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    August 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    June 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010

    Categories

    All
    1920s
    1950s
    1960s
    1970s
    1980s
    Aging
    Ask Jo
    Baby Cards
    Baby Clothes
    Baby Dresses
    Beyond The Us
    Book 1
    Book 2
    Book 3
    Boys
    Button On Suit
    Button-on Suit
    Child Consumers
    Children And Consumers
    Children As Consumers
    Color Symbolism
    Creepers
    Culture Wars
    Design Details
    Dress Codes
    Dress Up Play
    Dress-up Play
    Ethnicity
    Fashion And Age
    Feminism
    Garment Details
    Gender Binary
    Girls
    Hair
    Layettes
    Men
    Middle Childhood
    Neutral
    Pants For Girls
    Pink
    Pink For Boys
    Prenatal Testing
    Princesses
    Que Sera Sera
    Rants
    Research
    Rompers
    Sexuality
    Stereotypes
    Teens
    Toddlers
    Tomboys
    Transgender
    Unisex
    Unisex. 1970s
    Women
    Writing Updates

Proudly powered by Weebly